Showing posts with label automatic renewals gotcha capitalism trick deceptive business practices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label automatic renewals gotcha capitalism trick deceptive business practices. Show all posts

Friday, October 07, 2005

Automatic Renewals: Everyone's Doing It (and a Bit About Two-Part Tariff Pricing)

OK, I can't believe this!!

Downloading my Citibank records, I found a charge for "RoadRunner Club Renewal." Apparently, much like GQ magazine, RoadRunnerSports.com has taken the initiative to provide me a "service," automatically renewing my RoadRunnerSports Club membership. The membership provides faster shipping, a "free" return of shoes and 5% discount.

Here are three possible reasons people need to be renewed automatically:
1) The deal is very good if you order enough stuff to pay for the membership fee right off. If you are a real runner (which those of you who have seen me in person know is not the case at this point in my life), it's probably a decent deal. However, if you want to optimize your spending, it would make more sense to lump as many purchases together at a time and then be "inactive" until you need the discount/fast service again.

2) The economics for someone like me don't really make sense unless I buy a lot of stuff. Last year it was a heart monitor, about three pairs of shoes and some other things people find interesting if Mark Wahlberg (aka Marky Mark) was buying them. However, if you do the math, you'd have to buy a whole lot. The annual fee is $24.99 and this entitles you to 5% off your purchases, which means you'd have to buy $499.50 ($24.99/5%) to break even. For $38.98, you can save 10% on every order, but then your breakeven is $779.60. No wonder they had to automatically renew me!!

3) It's not really a club. Why do amateur marketers insist on calling everything a club? Who's stupid enough to think a two-part tariff pricing scheme is a club? It's a purely economic relationship.

Note that two-part tariff pricing, where you have an up front fixed price coupled with a per unit price, is very effective in the right situations. For RoadRunnerSports, it's really a way to get people who are buying a lot or expect to buy a lot to make a commitment to buy at least $500 worth of stuff (assuming they do the math). Industrial companies to this all the time. So do wireless phone companies when they charge a larger monthly fee up front and then give you more free minutes and lower per minute charges. Amazon does this when they charge you $3.00 to ship the first book and $0.99 for each additional book. This creates an incentive for the customer to buy more than the one thing they came for by effectively lowering the price of other items they might not have bought at a higher price.

The problem with the folks at RoadRunnerSports is they took a good idea (two-part pricing via the RoadRunner Club) and messed it up by automatically renewing membership.

Lesson: If you don't know why something works, you'll probably screw it up by trying to make more money off of it.

Saturday, February 12, 2005

Automatic renewals: When your magazine sucks, trap the customer

In yesterday's mail, I received a rather strident note from GQ magaine. The note came with an invoice - stated as the 3rd one they've sent - and threatening to send me to "outside collection" and asking me "For the small amount you owe, is it worth it to delay?"

I was kind of embarrassed and figured I should write the check immediately. I could have also paid my invoice on-line, but I don't typically do that for a simple reason: too many magazines are running a scam where they take your credit card number and - as a convenience - automatically bill you every time your subscription runs out. Hence, I am writing out a manual check when I realize, "Wait a minute! I've been thinking lately that GQ magazine kind of sucks. It's huge, but has little about fashion, style or upkeep anymore. Instead, the thing is chock full of advertising and articles on the most bizzare innane topics - like that damn mob family that has a reality TV show. I made a mental note that I wasn't going to renew my subscription."

I then realize I may not have actually renewed my GQ subscription - but the bastards are threatening to send me to a collection agency for not paying a subscription I didn't renew. After looking through my financial notes, I see no record of renewal, which is a bit odd for me not to have recorded.

I call GQ's customer service number, and they inform me that they did, in fact, renew my subscription "as a service" to me!! Unbeleivable!! I said one word, "unacceptable." The lady, keeping her composure, which isn't a total surprise, since I'm probably the tenth call like this she's received today, tells me she's canceled my subscription (which again, is odd, since I didn't renew it myself). I feel kind of weird about how cool she's being, particularly stating that "March will be your last issue and, if you receive another invoice, just ignore it and throw it out." (I think that means one is on the way. But still, she was really cool about it.) Overcome with her niceness, I explained that "I know you probably don't work for GQ, so I don't mean to be so curt to you. Thank you so much for your help and have a great day." Of course, this was insane - mostly on my part. Ms. Wonderful manages to not miss a beat and state, "Are you interested in golf? We have a special deal today on Golf Digest for only $12." Stunned by her opportunism, I could only mutter, "No thank you. Have a nice day. Goodbye."

***
Do you think GQ was really renewing my subscription as a service to me? I think not. I think it is a service to them. I figure some bonehead at GQ figured out that the best way to keep renewal rates up - and thus, subscribers - was to not let them leave. I might be wrong, but I doubt it. I find it very hard to believe that GQ (or their publisher, more accurately) did a market study and found subscribers beside themselves with regret for not having renewed their GQ subscription. All those customers just dying to get their hands on the latest story about the Gotti family and screaming for GQ to solve their problems with something really creative - like an automatic renewal service. (I love that they call this a service. The Orwellian double-speak is admirable.) No, this is a service to the publishers who have figured out that automatically renewing the subscriptions of indifferent subscribers is more profitable - since a large percentage probably don't dispute it - than trying to keep customers by addressing the editorial content. Of course, eventually advertisers will figure out that the response to ads in a magazine run this way is lower than advertising in a magazine people actually want - and the whole thing will backfire. Until then, the bonehead who thought this up gets a promotion and will fire the poor sap in charge of solicting advertisers a couple of years from now.

Hmmm...a good 45 minutes and a voided check later, all I can think is, "Thanks so much for your service. I can't imagine what I'd do without it. OK, I can, I'd be showered and shaved already instead of sitting in front of the computer ranting about your service..."